Inlet Cafe

Nestled right on the water’s edge in Highlands, New Jersey, Inlet Cafe offers a quintessential East Coast seafood dining experience that artfully combines fresh ocean flavors with a laid-back, scenic ambiance. This vibrant seafood restaurant and tiki bar is a beloved local hotspot that draws both seafood enthusiasts and casual diners keen on savoring the Atlantic’s finest bounty while soaking in panoramic beach views.

From the moment you arrive at 3 Cornwall Street, you’re welcomed by an inviting atmosphere that effortlessly balances casual seaside charm with a dash of tropical flair. Whether you choose to dine al fresco on the waterfront deck or settle in near the cozy tiki bar, the setting instantly sets a refreshing, vacation-inspired tone. Customers repeatedly praise the relaxing vibe—complete with well-curated music selections and attentive, friendly service—that makes every visit feel special and unhurried.

Inlet Cafe’s menu reads like a seafood lover’s dream, featuring a thoughtfully crafted selection that's both classic and inventive. Highlights include the iconic Lobster Roll, brimming with sweet lobster meat, crisp celery, and a subtle hint of apple, all nestled inside a buttery brioche roll. Equally enticing are the New England Clam Chowder, rich and creamy with tender clams, and the Crispy Fried Calamari and Bang-Bang Shrimp, each bite exploding with bold, satisfying textures and flavors.

For the adventurous palate, the Oysters Rockefeller and the Octopus dishes bring both refinement and freshness, perfectly capturing that coastal essence. The Stuffed Flounder and Lobster Mac and Cheese showcase the kitchen’s ability to elevate comfort food with fresh ingredients and thoughtful preparation. Not to be missed are the raw bar offerings straight from Neptune, like the East Coast Oysters and U8 Shrimp Cocktail, praised for their impeccable freshness.

Beyond seafood, Inlet Cafe excels with hearty handhelds such as the New Orleans Po Boy, packed with perfectly fried cod and Cajun remoulade, and the Café Burger, made from ground brisket and served on a soft brioche bun. For breakfast lovers, the menu tempts with fluffy pancakes or French toast, with options to add savory sides to make for a thoroughly satisfying start to the day.

The cocktail program shines just as brightly as the food, with inventive drinks like the Jalapeño Margarita and fruit-forward Sangria. Guests consistently highlight the quality and balance of cocktails, which range from lively frozen margaritas to colorful tiki-inspired libations. Happy hour enthusiasts will appreciate the generous pours and fair prices, as noted by many locals.

Reviews from patrons paint a vivid picture of what makes Inlet Cafe truly shine. Diners rave about the serene waterside dining experience, often appreciating both the attentive staff and the freshness of the food. One guest described the atmosphere as “very relaxing,” enjoying lunch overlooking the beach, while others were captivated by the combination of friendly bartenders, reasonably priced fare, and the unbeatable location “right next to the water.” Even on busy nights, the lively yet welcoming energy keeps guests wanting to linger with a cocktail in hand.

While some have noted occasional slow service or slightly higher prices on specialty cocktails, the overwhelming sentiment reflects that the exceptional quality, generous portions, and prime waterfront setting more than justify the experience. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick, flavorful lunch after a day at nearby Sandy Hook or settling in for an indulgent Lobster Night dinner, Inlet Cafe leaves a lasting impression.

For anyone seeking a seafood sanctuary by the sea with a vibrant tiki bar twist, Inlet Cafe is a standout destination where fresh ocean treasures meet warm hospitality and stunning views. It’s not just a meal—it’s a sensory escape into what the Jersey Shore does best.